I am doing a institution project and also was simply wondering what time period The Hobbit is based on. I am walk to read the publication soon yet i require to know if that is based on the middle eras or if that is based on an additional time period from out own timeline. I recognize The Hobbit takes location in middle-earth and that your timeline is different from ours.
You are watching: What year does the hobbit take place
Thank you because that the help!
If you want a simplistic answer, yes, that is based on the Middle periods (even though it isn't the center Ages, every se).
Having stated that, the genuine answer is a little bit more facility than that. Middle earth isn't really comparable to any one time duration in ours world. Locations like The Shire and also Laketown seem to evoke a duration as late as the 18th Century, when Gondor seems to evoke timeless antiquity.
In Tolkien's mind, the human being of Middle planet is collection in our very own prehistory, around 7000 years in the past, in Europe. That didn't fully decide on how the human being of the story must evolve right into our own, but the one idea the his that seems to stick is that Elves later returned come the Eriador, and also dug up a channel which came to be the English Channel, before continuing invasions drove them off again.
For extra points, I would certainly say it's not based on any real time period but rather motivated by european mythology - stories mainly written down during the middle Ages, however originating together oral heritages in the Dark Ages and earlier.
Tolkien was a scholar the Anglo-Saxon and also Norse mythology, translating messages such together Beowulf and also stories around King Arthur's knights.
To back up your argument, you might compare Gandalf come Merlin and also Odin. Gandalf is a name right from norseman mythology, as are numerous of the name of the Dwarves in The Hobbit. Tolkien's fantasy gyeongju of Elves and Dwarves room also adapted from vikings mythology, such as the Prose Edda.
This question is just way off base. There is no comparison to the timelines. Trying to carry out so is folly. Better to discuss the differences in ages and also how probably that corresponds to our periods ex. First age ancients, second age middle ages through imperialism, 3rd age industrial revolution, etc. However even that is a pretty compelled comparison.
Also, execute your own homework and also just check out the book, man. The Hobbit particularly occurs in a very minimal scope chronologically and also is the easiest review imo. Review it, type an opinion you can put a couple of text-based clues behind, and write it.
· 2y · edited 2y
Being a substantial sword nerd, and wanting to see if my favorite sword format would pass together Anduril (Aragorn from lord of the ring sword) I when made keep in mind of every cite of weapons and also armour throughout every one of Hobbit, LotR, Silmarillion, unfinished Tales, kids of Hurin, Beren and Luthien, and Fall of Gondolin. All this to show I did my research study to pin under a reasonably accurate “if it was our history” time.
While some of the clothing the Hobbits undertake is an extremely 1700-1800’s, the armour and also weaponry are all indigenous (likely) the migrate Era, about 500-800 C.E. This actually makes sense together Tolkien was hugely affected by Anglo-Saxon history and mythology, and that is the time period for every the background that influenced him.
Should you select to usage my suggest for class and need to support it: the only armour discussed is Chainmail (with just a couple of notable exceptions, and also only among those is in The Hobbit) and the swords that Thorin and Gandalf use are described as having jeweled hilts. The only historic swords found that room functional and have jeweled hilts are from the Vendel Era (google pics for vendel sword) which to be a small part of the migration Era.
Additionally the picture in the Hobbit that Bilbo in Smaug’s lair depicts number of Chainmail shirts, helms, spears, and shields that all aid to collection it in the hike Era.
See more: How Close Is Hawaii To California ? Is Hawaii Or California Closer To Alaska
As an aside, i’m so i was sure in mine findings that I’d fight your teacher if they disagreed.