We all remember the children nursery happiness about small Jack Horner. That the about the tiny boy that sticks his thumb into a pie and pulls out a plum. Pleased v himself, the declares, “What a an excellent boy am I!” far from being a unauthorized rhyme about a boy who likes to save his fingers in the pie, the nursery rhyme, little Jack Horner, speak the story of one actual person who steals much more than just a plum. 

You are watching: Stuck in his thumb pulled out a plum


Source: (mythsweliveby.tumblr.com)

Many Old English Nursery Rhymes had actually Hidden Meanings

Little Jack Horner is no unique among nursery rhymes. Numerous of the rhymes indigenous Old English appear to it is in harmless verses for youngsters on the outside, however when girlfriend read an ext into them and also look at the historic context in i m sorry they were written, you can see the they room actually making biting social commentary about people and also events that the time. 


Source: (etc.usf.edu)

Jack to be a real Person

The “Jack Horner” in the nursery happiness was really a human being named thomas Horner. In middle ages England, the surname “Jack” was regularly used in a generic sense to average a young boy, particularly a precocious one. Therefore in the ditty, Thomas’s name was changed to Jack, yet his last name stayed the same. 


King Henry VIII. Source: (englishhistory.net)

The Nursery Rhyme describes an Incident throughout the dissolution of the Monasteries

King Henry VIII bespeak the resolution of the monasteries to take it place between 1536 and 1541. The King basically shut under all the monasteries, friaries, convents, and other spiritual establishments all across England, Wales, and also Ireland and also seized the assets and incomes that these monasteries for the Crown. Much of the residential property that belonged to the churches to be sold and also the money sponsor the military campaigns of King Henry VIII throughout the 1540s. The resolution of the abbeys was met v resistance, and also many spiritual leaders sought special favors that the King in hopes that he would certainly exempt them indigenous the dissolution. 


Glastonbury Abbot. Source: (clasmerdin.blogspot.com)

Thomas Horner operated for the abbot of Glastonbury

During the time of the dissolved of the Monasteries, cutting board Horner to be the steward come Richard Whiting, who was the last abbot that Glastonbury. Whiting was one of the civilization trying to win Henry VIII’s donate in wishes of maintaining Glastonbury open. So he devised a clever plan to butter increase the king. Follow to legend, Whiting had actually a big pie baked simply for the King, however the pie organized a surprise. Hidden inside were the deeds to twelve manor dwellings that to be in the possession the the abduction of Glastonbury. Whiting hope to bribe the King through these surprised gifts.


Source: (cookit.e2bn.org)

Thomas Horner was sent to provide the Pie

It to be Christmas time, so cutting board Horner probably didn’t think the was too odd the the abduction was sending out him to London with a huge pie to give to the King together a gift. He was not aware that the pie hosted the deeds come a dozen manor houses. Something happened along the means and one of two people Horner obtained a tiny hungry or he simply slipped and also stuck his ignorance in the pie. Either way, the felt something unusual inside the dessert. He pulled the end the deed to Mells Manor. 

Mells Manor. Source: (bathselfcatering.com)

The Bribe Failed, but Horner had His ‘Plum’

King Henry VIII at some point received the Christmas pie, now with eleven deeds inside, however was not swayed through bribe attempt. The kidnapping of Glastonbury to be seized through the Crown along with nearly all the English monasteries. Horner’s boss, Richard Whiting, was the end of a job and also was executed because that treason. Yet quickly thereafter, cutting board Horner and his family members moved right into Mells Manor. As soon as questioned, Horner declared he purchase the manor residence from the King and also presented the deed as proof. Still, most people thought that Horner stole component of the bribe and also kept it because that himself. Horner’s descendants stayed living in ~ Mells Manor for plenty of generations. 

Medieval mining. Source: (spartacus-educational.com)

The Plum may not have Been a Plum

The Mells Manor, situated in Somerset, England, included a huge tract that land. Consisted of in the manor’s residential property were command mines in the Mendip Hills. The Latin word because that lead is plumbum and it to be not unusual for world in the Middle periods to describe lead together plum. For this reason when small Jack Horner pulled the end a plum from the pie, it could have supposed that the pulled the end a profitable lead mine. 

See more: Why Was John The Baptist In Jail And For How Long Was John The Baptist In Prison

Source: (npr.org)

The Pie might not have Been a Pie

It appears odd that the abduction would desire to hide the deeds come manor residences inside a small pie. It might be the the abbot to be trying to be an imaginative in his bribe attempt, however it must be listed that baking items right into desserts were not unheard of in England. There are textual references to coins, jewels, and also romantic verses created on paper all gift baked into pies or cakes as a means to surprise others. Part historians believe that the pie in the tiny Jack Horner nursery rhyme should be taken fairly literally and that the deeds were surprise under the flaky crust. Yet other researchers think that the pie to be a metaphor for a chest or box, in i m sorry the deeds were hidden. 

Source: (etc.usf.edu)

Was Horner a an excellent Boy?

The last line of the nursery luck has small Jack Horner exclaiming “Oh what a an excellent boy to be I!” some historians allude to this line as an interpretation that thomas Horner was happy with himself after discovering the deed to Mells Manor. No doubt he was worried around his livelihood after the closure the the kidnapping of Glastonbury, however he had actually in his possession the deed come a manor house, offering his family a place to live and also a potential income. King Henry had no method of understanding that the pie originally hosted twelve deeds, not eleven. And also Richard Whiting can not file theft charges versus Horner without admitting to bribing the King of England…and he was arrested and executed ~ above treason charges by stimulate of the King. Horner was in a an excellent position and also he knew it.