The constitution convention the 1787 to be formed and also tasked with the duty of propose amendments to The posts of Confederation besides coming up v a workable arrangement for the nationwide government. The two contentious plans were presented by the state of Virginia and new Jersey. Structurally, the 2 plans to be the same. Both were for the idea of 3 branches that Government, which were the legislature, judiciary, and the Executive.
You are watching: How were the virginia plan and the new jersey plan similar?
We will write a tradition Critical writing on Compare and contrast the Virginia and brand-new Jersey plans presented at the constitutional Convention especially for you for only $16.05 $11/page
301 certified writers online
In terms of congressional representation, the new Jersey setup proposed a unicameral house, i beg your pardon would permit all says equal depiction while the Virginia plan vouched for a bicameral residence that would have the house of Representatives chosen by people and the senate that would certainly be chosen by state legislatures (Foner 257). This depiction is feasible since congressional strength differs every state.
Each setup had services to the claims that to be vouching because that them. The tiny states to be vouching for same power because of the fear that the big states would certainly swallow them in the future due to their expansionist agenda. At the same time, they were merely securing source allocation come themselves versus the huge states (Foner 257). The large states to be securing the autonomous rights the their human being in regards to proportional representation, and decision making at the nationwide level v proportionate allocation that resources.
Both Alexander Hamilton and Thomas Jefferson were great diplomats (states’ rights) in the American society. Hamilton’s idea of the American governance system was based on the brother model through which he suggest a monarchy and also parliamentary system. Hamilton was never for the idea of says as he believed they were no necessary.
Rather, he sustained mercantilists and also companies (Foner 258). The was additionally a champion of the new constitution. Jefferson was a solid proponent that the state. The supported farming as the backbone the the economy. He believed in the freedom of the states as promoted in the ahead constitution.
Alexander Hamilton would certainly favor the Virginia plan, as he to be a federalist, because he to be a solid proponent of a less broken America with a more central government, which was powerful and come which all states would be subjected. He thought in the loosened interpretation of the constitution.
Thomas Jefferson would certainly favor the brand-new Jersey plan because he to be anti-federal (Foner 259), together he thought in much less power gift vested in the main government. He believed in the capacity of the individual says to retain strength besides favoring farming over industries.
The finished constitution defended slavery and the slave trade. In ~ the same time, it allowed different claims to enact regulation that would enable for the freedom of slaves, i beg your pardon paved way for the United states of America come pass regulation that one of two people abolished the servant trade or allowed the freeing of slaves.
The constitution motivated industrialization, which substantially enhanced mechanization in the cotton industry for this reason leading come less and less work force being required. It likewise led come the pass of anti-slavery regulations in the different states (Foner 258). The invoice of rights, as uncovered in the constitution, when taken later on, led to complete abolishment that the slave trade and slavery in all American states.
As a citizens of the brand-new America that 1790, ns would have favored Alexander Hamilton’s check out of mercantilists that urged industrialization and global trade (Foner 259) due to the fact that the whole civilization was opened up and also would permit the American human being to make use of the world’s sources besides trading v other countries competitively. In regards to the constitution plan, I would have obtained from both plans, as they both had actually exceptionally strong valid areas that are valuable for the American society.
See more: Things That Begin With The Letter B Jects That Start With B, List Of Objects That Start With B
Foner, Eric. Give me Liberty: an American History. Brand-new York: W.W Norton & Company, 2012. Print.